Yes, kids, it’s Banned Book Week this week.
I was reminded by reading Seraphim’s post on Megatokyo today. =/
Maybe I’m losing my passion as I get older, but the whole subject tires me out just thinking about it. No eloquent statements, no flowery prose, I’m just going to say book banners are fnerkin morons who should be flogged.
The arrogance and audacity of these people who feel they know what’s right for everyone else makes me angry, and tired. Back in high school and college I’d be up in arms ranting (er, audibly as opposed to compositionally as I’m doing now) over the subject of censorship (which is a misnomer, by the way…but more on that in a sec.)(OK, the sec’s here…)
Censorship is defined as governmental banning of material from any of its citizen’s ability to get it, not simply a group or a library or one bookstore not selling or loaning the item when you can get it elsewhere. It’s like the term “phobia.” People use whatever-phobia when they’re talking about simple fear or revulsion when phobia really means an EXTREMELY unreasonable fear to the point of harming yourself or another in order to avoid what you have a phobia of. But I digress.
Instead of copying the key points, take a read of Seraphim’s blog on Megatokyo, where she discusses a self-appointed police for morality working behind the scenes (and possibly illegally) to get the county library to rid itself of the horrible current policy that allows for access to damaging material like Harry Potter and S.E. Hinton books. The letter that was secretly sent to some of the members of the counsel often equates changing the policy and breaking free of the permissiveness of the American Library Association with Bush’s campaign against Iraq. (Regardless of my pro-Iraqi war feelings, and the war is a necessary evil, but an evil none the less, and Bush is a corrupt idiot and any morality movement that equates itself with that jackass and with a war (necessary or not) is a frightening thing.)
Becoming a parent has certainly changed my opinion on some things, like violence and sex in the media. Before being a parent, I was all for it saying “a good parent can teach their kids right from wrong regardless of what’s in the media.” Yeesh! The extremely violent and sexually charged TV and cartoons and commercials and all sure does make it VERY tough. And regardless of how hard I try to bring my daughter up with a critical mind and an ethical heart, there’s still peers and adults out there who are damaged by society’s amorality (notice I said a-morality and not im-morality) and will seek to make her a victim. It’s enough to give me panic attacks every other day. And don’t get me started on the Internet. I used to be an advocate of completely open and free Internet…until I started getting pop-up ads and spam everyday for sites where I can see teens doing horses while getting body part enlargement while better mortgage interest rates. You get my point. And more to the point, it seems like once a week I read about some girl that got killed, kidnapped, raped, or assaulted from a secret meeting with someone met on the Internet. Panic attack time.
HOWEVER, I will never change my opinion regarding public libraries. I don’t care if it’s Mein Kampf, the Bible, deSade’s 120 Days of Sodom, or the Velveteen Rabbit, every book and every idea “good” or “bad” should be available in the library. These are bastions of free speech, free expression of ideas, and people should be able to go there and read anything they want whether it’s something they agree with or something that challenges them and makes them think. I want my daughter to be able to go to the library and read the insane rantings of a mad dictator in the making, so she can better understand what allowed the horrors of the Third Reich to occur, I want her to be able to read on other religions and see what ethics are a part of other cultures to better understand them, I want her to be able to read about “bad” things and how the characters overcome them so she can learn about the world she has to live in. A person that’s sheltered from everything except only what they already believe in is an ignorant fool who is incapable of critical thinking and either becomes a gullable dupe or a bullheaded moron.
And it’s the library. You have to GO to the library and seek out the “bad” things. It’s not like TV which comes openly into your house with next to no checks and balances. If you want to avoid reading “bad” things in a library, don’t go. Don’t let your kids go. (Although if your kids disobey you and sneak out to the library and learn dissenting views, good for them! Better than sneaking out to party with unsafe sex and drugs.)
Not to mention the fact that the free republic we live in has a responsibility to its public to make available all the interests of its people. (Well, I’ll agree, books that detail how to make pipebombs and how to assassinate people aren’t really for the public interest. You should have to probably work real hard to get access to those.) All taxpayers pay for the library, not just the Moral Majority or the Religious Reich…er, Right. Everyone. So it must serve everyone, not just people who are too stupid or lazy to think for themselves and feel other people shouldn’t think.
And what kills me, is if you look at the list of banned and challenged books, most are books where the moral, the theme, the plot, has to do with overcoming the topics they’re being challenged for. “The Chocolate War,” “Huck Finn”, “Julie of the Wolves”, “I know Why The Caged Bird Sings”, “Bridge to Terabithia”, these are books that deal with overcoming fear, racism, hatred, (wait, those are topics the Religious Reich uses to keep people in line and convince themselves they’re right and everyone else is wrong! Critical thinking senses tingling…). They help kids and young adults learn about tough decisions and situations and how to deal with them. Let’s face it, after a certain age kids don’t listen to their parents as much as they used to. But if they grow up learning to read (beyond a gradeschool level, and material other than Powerpuff Girls,) they will read books by S.E. Hinton, Stephen King, Maya Angelou, Louis Sachar, and will be able to confirm ethical behavior and true morality that’s open minded that their parents hopefully planted the seeds of. If all a person reads is the Bible and other religious propaganda, all they learn is ignorance, intolerance, hatred, arrogance, and all the other values that makes religions, societies, cultures war with others and within themselves. Completely off the subject (well, not really,) I say it again: Religion is the worst thing to ever happen to faith.